Image: apnews.com
The Story
The California list contained possible leads, not 20,000 established illegal votes.
This was a high-stakes federal data exercise that did not meet the transparency and verification demands of an election intervention. Local officials, analysts, and judges identified mismatches, apparent citizens, unclear sourcing, and serious timing problems. The DOJ may have identified some genuine cases, but the available reporting does not support treating the entire list as reliable without individual review.
- VerificationNames drawn from conflicting government records require case-by-case confirmation before ballots are segregated or voters are accused.
- Due processA rushed demand affecting thousands of ballots risks disenfranchisement when the underlying data cannot be independently audited.
- More than 40% of names in the DOJ list were reported not to appear on California voter rolls in an analysis reviewed by AP.
- Initial local reviews found some people on the list appeared to be U.S.-born, and California officials called the list unreliable.
- A Ninth Circuit panel questioned both DOJ’s jurisdiction and the reliability and sourcing of its list.
Source mix
11 sources
- 8 News reporting
- 2 Forum, video, personal
- 1 Other / unclassified
Deeper Insight
The DOJ’s thumb drive turned bad matches into a 48-hour election threat. In this game, suspicion moves faster than proof.
A thumb drive, a password on a Post-it, and 48 hours. That was the DOJ’s package for roughly 20,000 alleged noncitizen voters, despite warnings of false positives and names missing from voter rolls. Courts stopped the demands within a day. The danger is bigger than one bad list: fear itself can become an election tool.
- What it could changeCourts could force election investigations to prove each name before putting a ballot at risk.
- How it touches todayA database match can still make an ordinary voter defend their citizenship on someone else’s deadline.
- Our futureElections could be shaped by allegations that never survive a careful check.
- The DOJ reportedly demanded that California investigate the listed allegations within 48 hours after delivering the list on a thumb drive.
- Researchers reported thousands of names they could not match to current California voter-registration records; the DOJ disputed their analysis and sought sanctions.
- Internal warnings described HSI’s platform as likely to produce very large numbers of false positives, while the nationwide effort yielded only a few dozen prosecutions and fewer convictions.
Sources · 11
- 8 News reporting
- 2 Forum, video, personal
- 1 Other / unclassified
What do these mean?
- News reporting. Journalism: newspapers, magazines and news sites.
- Forum, video, personal. Forums, social posts, video, blogs and personal accounts.
- Other / unclassified. A site we have not classified yet. This says nothing good or bad about it.
Featured · Analysis · techdirt.com
DOJ Admits Its ‘Illegal Voter’ Lists Can’t Be Trusted, Leading To Three Court Losses In 24 Hours
News reporting
A last minute attempt to throw the midterm election into chaos failed. Leading up to this point, the signs were never good in the Magic 8 Ball way. The Trump administration wants people to believe California was overrun with non-citizen voters. The facts, however, refuse to comply with the narrative. This particular ship has been sinking for a couple of weeks now. The DOJ delivered an accusation b
Read sourceAnalysis · propublica.org
How Trump's Unprecedented Effort to Prosecute Noncitizen Voters Fell Apart — ProPublica
News reporting
How Trump's Unprecedented Effort to Prosecute Noncitizen Voters Fell Apart — ProPublica Illustration by Matt Rota for ProPublica. Animation by Henrike Lendowski for ProPublica. # Inside Trump’s Failed Hunt for Noncitizen Voters by Peter Elkind, Jen Fifield, Doug Bock Clark, Ken B. Morales and Andy M
Read sourceAnalysis · thedingodave.substack.com
DOJ Seeks Possible Contempt Charges Against Lawyers Who Challenged Its California Voter List
Forum or personal account
DOJ Seeks Possible Contempt Charges Against Lawyers Who Challenged Its California Voter List ### The Justice Department is asking a federal judge to consider contempt proceedings against lawyers and voting-rights researchers who examined a government list of 20,930 suspected noncitizen voters Dingo
Read source