Investigated
Are there documented cases of wildlife misidentification?
Evidence strength: Documented wildlife misidentification is firmly established across hunting, field surveys, monitoring programs, and photographic observation. The remaining disagreement concerns how frequent errors are in particular settings and how best to reduce them, not whether they occur.
Short answer
Image: link.springer.com
Yes. Researchers and wildlife managers have documented animals being mistaken for similar species—or even domestic animals—including protected swans shot as other swans, a husky mistaken for a wolf, and bird, fish, mussel, track, and scat identification errors. The evidence also shows that misidentification can distort population estimates and conservation decisions, especially when species are visually similar or evidence is indirect. Genetic confirmation and stronger training often expose errors that field observation misses.