Weighing mainstream and alternative accounts…
Image: pixabay.com
Are confident, detailed eyewitness accounts often stories shaped by investigators rather than faithful recollections of events?
Cognitive and legal-psychology research treats eyewitness testimony as neither uniformly reliable nor uniformly worthless. Memory is affected by attention and stress at encoding, then by retrieval, misinformation, questioning, and source confusion. The strongest practical implication is procedural: obtain an early, uncontaminated account, avoid suggestive questioning, and interpret later confidence cautiously.
Source mix
7 of 7 institutional
Investigators don't just collect eyewitness memories. With every interview and leading question, they can help build them.
A witness starts with fragments: a face half seen, a color, a sound. Then come the interviews, the detailed prompts, the gentle push to be sure. By the courtroom, the fragments have become a confident, emotional story. In one study, about 50% of people took on details from misleading questions. A memory can be built in plain sight, and the builder may be the person asking.
Featured · Primary source · pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Convicting with confidence? Why we should not over-rely on eyewitness confidence
Journal · peer-reviewed
Convicting with confidence? Why we should not over-rely on eyewitness confidence ## Abstract Eyewitness memory researchers have recently devoted considerable attention to eyewitness confidence. While there is strong consensus that courtroom confidence is problematic, we now recognise that an eyewitn
Read sourcePrimary source · nature.com
Adults are just as susceptible to memory suggestibility when reporting about single and repeated events | Scientific Reports
Journal · peer-reviewed
Adults are just as susceptible to memory suggestibility when reporting about single and repeated events | Scientific Reports ## Abstract Exposure to misleading suggestive questions can distort adults’ memory for single events, but it is unclear whether this is also the case following a repeated even
Read sourceAnalysis · cell.com
The cognitive science of eyewitness memory: Trends in Cognitive Sciences
Journal · peer-reviewed
The cognitive science of eyewitness memory: Trends in Cognitive Sciences # The cognitive science of eyewitness memory Laura Mickes Laura Mickes Correspondence Correspondence: Send email to [email protected] School of Psychological Science, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK 1 Send email to
Read sourceA University of Virginia study of 1,678 children's past-life claims finds shorter gaps before rebirth after sudden deaths.
6 sourcesBrain scans of 1,300 people link mild cognitive impairment to a shared memory network.
3 sourcesAre recovered-memory therapies manufacturing vivid abuse memories that never happened, upending families and courts?
10 sourcesA former pupil of Zimbabwe’s Ariel School recounts seeing a spaceship and three beings in a new interview.
5 sourcesIceberg I is turning a rumored eyewitness network into a hunt for physical evidence.
6 sourcesThe Virtual Experience Model says UAP encounters may happen inside human consciousness.
10 sources